Scenario management plays a vital role in a world of irrelevant budgets and inaccurate forecasts.
The Seattle FP&A Board met on May 24th. Ron Zanetti, Head Of Finance at WellSaid Labs and FP&A Board Ambassador moderated the discussion. 28 professionals attended from companies, including:
- Amazon
- Boeing
- T-Mobile
- Genie/Terex Corporation
- Seattle Children’s Hospital
Figure 1: Lively Networking During the Seattle FP&A Board
Lessons Learned From the Pandemic
During introductions, all the participants provided insight into lessons learned from the pandemic. The following are some of the comments made:
- We could respond to remote work in the short term, but it became more complex in the long term
- There is a need for face-to-face collaboration
- Don’t be distracted by the noise and how it affects the long-term direction of the company
- Increase the cadence of forecasting to enable companies to “win at the turns”
- Raise cash before the market tanks
- Make sure you understand the balance sheet and break-even point
- Don’t take growth for granted
Scenarios
One of the discussion topics was effective Scenario Planning. The following are some of the insights and comments provided by participants.
- Scenarios must be accurate, believable and timely
- Build a connection across the organization to achieve good scenarios
- Scenarios based on cash flow and balanced sheets provide the foundation for accuracy
- Don’t over-rely on averages in scenario planning because you may miss big things
- Need to have a gut check on the assumptions that underlie scenarios
xP&A Discussion
One of the discussion topics was on xP&A. The following are some characteristics identified of effective xP&A processes and solutions.
- Processes and workflows are executed across functions and entities, not just within entities
- Finance and operations share planning models that support both
- In manufacturing, sales and operations and Rolling Forecast should be a single process
- Effective cross-functional management, like the use of productivity measures instead of fixed budget targets
- The Group pushed back on the concept of xP&A as the feeling was that it did not adequately address the need for integration as stated. We ended up with a new format: (xP&A)I, where the power of I = integration. So we turned it into calculus.
Breakout Teams
At the end of the meeting, participants broke into three groups, each addressing one topic. The following is a summary of their feedback.
Team 1: What are the practical steps in implementing xP&A?
- Repeatable
- Solid Strategic Plan
- Collaborate with all functional groups and execs
- Finance: set guardrails to help participants
- Strong Leadership
- Set a calendar and timeline for all
- Set a Planning Cadence
Team 2: How to move from traditional planning to Scenario Management?
- Invest time and establish a framework (tools and process to handle iterations)
- The organization’s incentives aligned
- Build trust with stakeholders; key stakeholders must understand the impact of financial statements
- KPIs across the entire business
- Find allies/change agents, champions, influencers
- Find and turn around one sceptic into a champion
- Ensure calendar management and sustain an operating rhythm
- Manage resource allocation for people first
- Be mindful of controllable and non-controllable factors
Team 3: How can organizations prepare themselves for successful analytical transformation?
- Ensure decisions are driven by data
- Recruit champions
- Communicate vision
- Demonstrate and share “Actionable Insights”, not just “Interesting Insights”.
SAP, Seattle Search Group and International Workplace Group sponsored the meeting.