FP&A Week: Breaking the Paradox
October 10-13, 2023
By Stéphane Bonutto, CFO at Oerlikon Balzers
In many companies, the processes and tools to manage profit and loss (P&L) are quite developed, but the cash flow is not always understood and does not always receive the same level of attention. What are the reasons for this and how can FP&A improve the situation?
In most cases, a positive profit result goes hand in hand with a positive cash flow. But some managers do not understand why in selected cases the two numbers can have different outcomes.
A reason for this may be the relatively complex definition of cash flow when compared to the company’s overall result. While the profit is basically revenue minus cost, the cash flow also includes CAPEX, inventory, creditors, debtors and customer or supplier advances. Some of these financial elements may not always be tangible enough for people to understand. On top of this, different terminologies are often discussed such as operating cash flow or free cash flow.
Firstly, the cash flow is a closer indicator of the company’s ability to remunerate its owners. In small companies, the cash flow position determines how much the owners can withdraw for their personal compensation. In large companies, it represents the value of dividends that can be paid without affecting the cash reserves of the company.
Secondly, the cash flow illustrates whether a company can finance an investment, with or without bank support. For any bank loan, the bank requests an accurate assessment of the client’s cash flow position in order to plan the amounts that can be lent reliably.
As a starting point, finance should make all of the cash flow elements transparent and understandable to the entire staff. Then clear responsibilities should be assigned to specific departments that can take effective actions. Since I have already addressed CAPEX management in a previous blog, here I will concentrate on the drivers of the net working capital (NWC).
In manufacturing companies, inventories are a major element of the NWC, along with their associated raw materials, spare parts, semi-finished and finished products. Depending on the size of the company, inventories will be the responsibility of the production department, or the responsibility will be split between supply chain and production. Target inventory values should be determined in relation to the sales level.
In my opinion, the collection of debts is not the sole responsibility of the finance department. On the contrary, it should involve sales support and the customer-facing salesforce. Accounting should take care of the debt chasing and work out the root causes for overdue payments. The sales department should follow up on these cases during their customer contact until the payment is resolved. In order to decrease the risk of debt write-off, customers credit checks should be carried out ahead of new orders and on a regular basis.
Amounts payable are largely impacted by discounts and payment terms. The optimisation of these parameters usually involves the purchasing and finance departments. Procurement, or the purchasing department, is typically focused on achieving material cost savings from year to year as well as selecting the optimal supplier for new materials and services. Finance should ensure that the negotiated payment terms are at least in line with industry standards. Any improvement of payment terms from year to year also contributes to the company cash flow position.
Finance should primarily determine a common and stable cash flow report across the company. Ideally, the cash flow statements should be displayed in a clear way. In most cases, the cash flow is derived from the profit, CAPEX and net working capital, referred to as the indirect calculation.
In order to receive the same level of attention as the result, the cash flow should be part of all regular planning and reporting processes. Especially in companies who are subject to P&L statement submissions. Key driver analysis should also be performed for the cash flow and the P&L. The position of inventories, debtors and creditors should be measured in relation to sales, e.g. in terms of days.
Finally, similar to the P&L, the cash flow position should be budgeted and forecasted. For this purpose, clear objectives and rewards should be assigned to operational leader across production, logistics, sales and purchasing. As with cost drivers, this assignment of responsibility should ensure that the cash flow drivers receive adequate focus during the year.
The article was first published in Unit4 Prevero Blog
In this article, we will look at why financial planning and analysis (FP&A) tends to not...
In spite of knowing that cash is critical for success, how many businesses and various teams...
In this article, I will explain to you what I learned about Cash this year and...
The purpose of a statement of cash flows is to describe how businesses receive and spend...
Working in FP&A during a crisis is extremely challenging but it is also an opportunity to...
We will regularly update you on the latest trends and developments in FP&A. Take the opportunity to have articles written by finance thought leaders delivered directly to your inbox; watch compelling webinars; connect with like-minded professionals; and become a part of our global community.