Skip to main content
Home
The Online Resource for Modern FP&A Professionals
Please register to receive the latest FP&A news, updates and tips Login

Main menu

  • Home
  • FP&A Insights
    • FP&A Trends Digest
    • FP&A Trends Research
    • FP&A Trends Insight Paper
    • FP&A Trends Survey
    • Short Videos
    • Our Contributors
  • FP&A Events
    • International FP&A Board
    • FP&A Trends Webinars
    • Digital FP&A Circles
  • AI/ML Committee
    • Introduction
    • Members
    • Resources
    • Meetings
  • FP&A Tools
    • FP&A Trends Maturity Model
  • About Us
    • Company Policy
    • Privacy Policy
    • Editorial Guidelines
    • Our Ambassadors
    • Our Sponsors & Partners
    • Contact Us
image
Finance Silos and How to Avoid These
April 24, 2020

By Amrish Shah, CFO at Metabolic

FP&A Tags
FP&A Skills
FP&A Team Building
FP&A Transformation

financeThe word “silo” (originations relating to agriculture and an isolated structure for storing grains) has over the past few years been used to denote a negative aspect of organisational culture.

The reason why is not hard to see. The image of a silo is one that is sealed off from its surroundings. It is insular and protected. In the organisation, this has tended to manifest itself in functional silos. Meaning Finance, HR, IT, R&D, Supply Chain, Marketing etc. It can, of course, apply broader to also divisions within an organisation or even regions / markets.

Why are silos thought of so negatively? I’ll highlight 3 reasons.

Philosophical: “No man is an island unto himself”. There are very, very few instances where any work these days is done without any interaction with others. 

Environmental: The nature of modern organisation life is getting more and more complex due to the combined effect of globalisation, increased risk and technological advances. This fuels the need for the solving of more complex problems and confronting more decisions to be made at higher levels of uncertainty. This requires more, not less collaboration and holistic thinking.

Social: As humans, we spend an inordinate amount of time at work. At heart, we are a social species. At the same time, our “lizard brain” still makes us feel faintly suspicious of “the other”. In general, familiarity breeds increased levels of security. Hence, an environment where siloed behaviour is encouraged is likely to be one that breeds more suspicion and uncertainty than trust and confidence.

Applicability to Finance

How does this relate to Finance? As long as any organisation unit has different components the risk is there that these components work independent of each other. In a typical (core) finance function, one may find the following sub-functions:

  • Financial Accounting
  • Financial Planning & Reporting
  • Business Control / Commercial FP&A
  • Tax
  • Treasury
  • Internal Control / Audit

How can silo behaviour exhibit itself within finance?

Narrow focus. Focus is normally good, but a failure to look at the big picture and define too narrowly the purpose of the role can lead to ignoring dependencies and interdependencies.

Differing temperaments. Typically, the types of personalities, skillsets and mindsets found in the different sub-functions tend to differ. This makes by nature, collaboration harder. Understanding the world of the other is often felt as an inconvenience, especially when neck high in the operations swamp.

Lack of collaboration moments. If the only collaboration moments are handover moments, in other words, passing some kind of information over, then the chances are high that the walls of the silo limit the boundaries of taking responsibility. To go beyond the wall so to speak.
 
Information is power. Finance ultimately deals with information. That is its “product / service” to the business. In the past information had a scarcity value. Now that is much less so. In that environment adopting a hoarding mentality is counterproductive.

Consequences

This can lead to, amongst others, the following consequences:

A blame culture, especially when things go wrong, normally around reporting or controls.

Dis-synergies, meaning that in terms of providing solutions for the customers of finance these solutions are likely to be sub-optimal, due to a lack of finance integrated thinking and action.

Lack of any kind of finance identity, leading to different sub-cultures within finance.

Barriers to talent management and career development. This is perhaps the most important consequence. Especially if the purpose of the function is to continue to become stronger and to develop stronger finance leaders.

Prevention

So, what are ways to stop this happening? In any silo situation, it starts with the tone at the top. With the CFO. They need to acknowledge that this is an issue that is holding the function back. It is either causing demonstrable damage or getting in the way of achieving objectives.

Breaking historic and current silo behaviour is a question of managing change. Therefore, it is also important to note that it starts and ends with people. Technology, behavioural nudges, incentives, consequences will all have a role to play, but to move from necessary to sufficient – the willingness of the people in the function is critical.

Concretely, I would highlight six things that a CFO can address to start to break down these internal walls.

Ensure that the Finance LT is committed to this and the ongoing FLT agenda reflects the importance of this. After all, on the FLT are likely to be the heads of each sub-function and therefore people who will have to live with the change.

Make the case for the change. Illustrate concrete examples of where there has been unnecessary friction, frustration, noise, regretted losses, lost opportunities to improve service levels and, therefore, credibility.

Create opportunities for deeper collaboration. Moving away from silo behaviour comes much more naturally when people get to work with each other more and they get to know each other better

Demand and facilitate information sharing across the function about how well the different parts of the finance are doing. Share KPIs. Share performance results of the business. 

Involve the people in the function to design what positive behaviours they would like to see in an integrated one finance environment compared with the past. Enshrine these behaviours and focus on peer and leadership recognition of these especially in the early periods of the shift.

Last but not least, involve the business. Let them know about the shift that the function is attempting. Enlist their help in calling out when they still see signs of the silo at work in finance. 

In many ways the rise of technology as a catalyst for finance transformation (think Intelligent Automation, Robotic Process Automation, Algorithms, Data Analytics and Visualisation amongst others) can increasingly break down such silos by giving a common language – that of systems, technology and data – to speak. Another example is in the continued use of collaborative technology to bring people closer together.

Summary

Ultimately, the problems faced by organisations only get more complex and that requires finance as a function to step up in its abilities to deliver end to end business solutions that will lead to supporting a healthier business in the future. This requires – just as in the whole business – a real and demonstrable shift from a narrow, boundary defined, responsibility to a broader, collaborative, dependent view of the real outcomes expected of the finance function as a unit. Without active support and drive from the CFO and their LT, any efforts to move to such a place are likely to fail. 
 

The full text is available for registered users. Please register to view the rest of the article.
  • Log In
  • or
  • Register

Related articles

FP&A Can Undergo Transformation Through Organisational Structure? Tell Us How!
September 22, 2017

On 11th May 2017 the Zurich FP&A Board gathered 36 senior finance practitioners from such leading...

Read more
Is Your Organisation Encouraging Effective Collaboration?
July 10, 2019

Collaboration is important, as “goes without saying”: “We must collaborate to solve this problem” or “They...

Read more
How FP&A Teams Can Successfully Cooperate with Other Departments
December 17, 2018

The below article summarises an approach developed throughout the years of my work and explores ways...

Read more
+

Subscribe to
FP&A Trends Digest

We will regularly update you on the latest trends and developments in FP&A. Take the opportunity to have articles written by finance thought leaders delivered directly to your inbox; watch compelling webinars; connect with like-minded professionals; and become a part of our global community.

Create new account

image

Event Calendar

Pagination

  • Previous
  • May 2025
  • Next
Su Mo Tu We Th Fr Sa
27
28
29
30
1
2
3
 
 
 
 
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
Transforming FP&A Together: Human & AI Synergy
 
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
Moving from FP&A to Extended Planning and Analysis (xP&A)
 
Five Critical Roles for Building a World-Class FP&A Team
 
25
26
27
28
29
30
31
FP&A Business Partnering and AI: A New Era
 
All events for the year

Future Meetings

The Face-to-Face Amsterdam FP&A Board
The Face-to-Face Amsterdam FP&A Board Transforming FP&A Together: Human & AI Synergy

May 15, 2025

The Face-to-Face Milan FP&A Board
The Face-to-Face Milan FP&A Board Moving from FP&A to Extended Planning and Analysis (xP&A)

May 20, 2025

The Face-to-Face Frankfurt FP&A Board
The Face-to-Face Frankfurt FP&A Board Five Critical Roles for Building a World-Class FP&A Team

May 22, 2025

BPAI
The FP&A Trends Webinar FP&A Business Partnering and AI: A New Era

May 28, 2025

The Face-to-Face London FP&A Board: Data Management & Analytics: Unlocking FP&A Value
The Face-to-Face London FP&A Board Mastering Data in FP&A: Smarter Analytics, Better Decisions

June 5, 2025

FP&A Trends Webinar The Evolving Role of FP&A: From Number Cruncher to Strategic Advisor
The FP&A Trends Webinar Making FP&A Teams Fit for the Future

June 11, 2025

The Face-to-Face New York FP&A Board
The Face-to-Face New York FP&A Board From Insight to Impact: FP&A Business Partnering in Action

June 17, 2025

The Face-to-Face Sydney FP&A Board
The Face-to-Face Sydney FP&A Board Modern Financial Planning and Analysis (FP&A): Latest Trends and Developments

June 26, 2025

The Face-to-Face Singapore FP&A Board: Modern Financial Planning and Analysis (FP&A): Latest Trends and Developments
The Face-to-Face Singapore FP&A Board Modern Financial Planning and Analysis (FP&A): Latest Trends and Developments

July 8, 2025

AI/ML FP&A
AI/ML FP&A
Data and Analytics
Data & Analytics
FP&A Case Studies
FP&A Case Studies
FP&A Research
FP&A Research
General
General
Integrated FP&A
Integrated FP&A
People and Culture
People and Culture
Process
Process
Technology
Technology

Please register to receive the latest FP&A news, updates and tips.

info@fpa-trends.com​

              

Foot menu

  • FP&A Insights
  • FP&A Board
  • FP&A Videos

Footer countries

  • Amsterdam
  • Austin
  • Boston
  • Brisbane
  • Brussels
  • Chicago
  • Copenhagen
  • Dubai
  • Frankfurt
  • Geneva
  • Helsinki
  • Hong Kong
  • Houston
  • Kuala Lumpur
  • London Board
  • London (Circle)
  • Melbourne
  • Miami
  • Milan
  • Munich
  • New York
  • Paris
  • Perth
  • Riyadh
  • San Francisco
  • Seattle
  • Shanghai
  • Singapore
  • Stockholm
  • Sydney
  • Tokyo
  • Toronto
  • Washington D.C.
  • Zurich

Copyright © 2025 fpa-trends.com. All rights reserved.

0