The FP&A Trends Webinar: Digitised FP&A Business Partnering: The Formula for Success
Click here to view details and register
The FP&A Trends Webinar: Digitised FP&A Business Partnering: The Formula for Success
Click here to view details and register
By Marco Singh, Commercial Finance Director at Ensono
Forecasting new product launches are a tricky business with plenty of emotional baggage. They are also often, inevitably, wrong. This blog argues that when commercial finance or FP&A professionals are involved they should focus equally on model flexibly as well as the outcome.
‘If you can look into the seeds of time, and say which grain will grow and which will not, speak then unto me.’– Shakespeare
The web is littered with quotes from famous people talking about how difficult the future is to predict. The same applies to business, as outlined in this article McKinsey Forecasting. Forecasting sales of new products is no different. It’s a tricky business packed with political and emotional baggage as well.
Every product launch will have a business case, and behind every business case, there will be a forecast model. Certainly, best practices need to be followed when building the model(s) and producing a forecast - and a helpful overview of challenges and insights can be found in this study KPMG Economist Forecasting, which is still relevant today. For example:
As long as your model is able to reflect how costs vary with volume (see these links for an often neglected perspective on this HBR Sales Learning Curve; ACCA Learning Curve it’s almost always better to focus on ensuring your model can be dynamic - able to reflect scenarios such as different business driver inputs, channel mix, forecasting methodologies, timeframes and volumes.
That is not to say the important role of Finance as an impartial seeker of accuracy should be ignored. However the finance professional should be careful how much effort to put into creating a forecast. The forecast is inevitably going to be ‘wrong’ and often the focus can mistakenly be on aspects of a model that will only deliver spurious levels of accuracy.
Hopefully, there will be a monitoring process for product launches post event (and if there isn’t you should create one) and it is key that not just the revenues and volumes are tracked.
Before producing a reforecast, every effort should be made to track the underlying non-financial KPIs as these are most likely to impact your modelling assumptions. Sales & Marketing teams should also provide their insights based on any qualitative feedback that becomes available. If you’ve got a flexible model, chances are that it will be able to cope with the new driver data, and edge you towards a better reforecast.
Commercial finance / FP&A need to be involved in forecasting new product launches, but must accept that pinpoint accuracy is a mission impossible. Instead, they should focus on building a model that can cope with flexibility and new information. Also, there can be lots of pressure to deliver a reforecast, but holding off until there is new, tangible, business driver data can make all the difference. In the words of Shakespeare: ‘Give every man thy ear, but few thy voice.’
The article was first published in Unit4 Prevero Blog
Many millions of people are stuck with the habit of smoking. They know its bad for...
The first step in forecasting is to understand where we are today and how we arrived...
Sometimes, what you forecast needs to change dramatically, due to e.g. market disruption or internal changes...
We will regularly update you on the latest trends and developments in FP&A. Take the opportunity to have articles written by finance thought leaders delivered directly to your inbox; watch compelling webinars; connect with like-minded professionals; and become a part of our global community.